SUPERDEBATE VS POLICY DEBATE
The accessible alternative to competitive college debate
What is Policy Debate?
Policy Debate (CX) is the dominant competitive format in American high schools and colleges. Teams spend months researching a single topic, compile extensive evidence files, and often speak at speeds exceeding 300 words per minute. While intellectually rigorous, it requires substantial time, money, and specialized training to compete.
SuperDebate was created as the modern alternative - capturing the intellectual challenge of competitive debate while removing the barriers that exclude working professionals, casual competitors, and anyone who cannot dedicate 20+ hours per week to preparation.
The SuperDebate Format
Constructive
Build and present your original arguments. Make your case clearly and persuasively.
Cross-Examination
Question your opponent. Clarify positions and expose weaknesses in their arguments.
Rebuttal
Respond to your opponent's arguments and reinforce your own. Deliver your closing.
That's it. Three speech types, infinitely configurable. From 18-minute quick rounds to 60+ minute deep dives.
SuperDebate vs Policy Debate
| Feature | SuperDebate | Policy Debate (CX) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation Time | Zero prep - topics assigned at event | Months of evidence cutting and research |
| Speaking Style | Natural, conversational delivery | Spreading (300+ WPM) common and expected |
| Entry Barrier | Show up and compete - no training needed | Requires extensive coaching and practice |
| Cost to Compete | Free or minimal event fees | $1000s in travel, camps, and coaching |
| Time Commitment | Single events, flexible attendance | Year-round commitment required |
| Age/Status | Open to all ages and backgrounds | Primarily high school and college students |
| Team Size | 1v1 to 5v5 (flexible) | 2v2 only (fixed) |
| Duration | 18-60+ min (4 presets) | ~90 min (fixed) |
| Judging Criteria | Clear rubric: logic, delivery, responsiveness | Technical flow, often favors speed readers |
| Spectator Friendly | Anyone can follow and enjoy | Unintelligible to untrained observers |
Why SuperDebate is Built for Everyone
Zero Prep Required
No evidence cards, no research blocks, no tubs of files. Topics assigned at the event. Your wit is your weapon.
Speak Like a Human
No spreading. No jargon. Debate at a pace audiences can follow and judges can evaluate fairly.
Open to Everyone
Adults, professionals, parents, retirees. Not just students. Anyone can compete from day one.
Low Time Investment
Compete when you want. No weekly practices, no weekend tournaments, no year-round commitment required.
Pure Argumentation
Win on thinking, not on who has more evidence. Real-time reasoning beats pre-written blocks.
Inclusive Competition
Climb ranks based on skill, not resources. No advantage for expensive camps or private coaching.
Common Questions
Other Format Comparisons
Ready to Try Modern Debate?
5-10 min prep time on the spot. No experience required. Just show up and compete.