SUPERDEBATE VS LINCOLN-DOUGLAS DEBATE
The accessible alternative to values-based 1v1 debate
What is Lincoln-Douglas Debate?
Lincoln-Douglas (LD) debate is a values-based 1v1 format named after the historic 1858 Lincoln-Douglas senatorial debates. It's the primary individual debate format in American high school competition, governed by the National Speech & Debate Association (NSDA).
LD requires debaters to establish a value (like justice, liberty, or equality) and a criterion (the framework for weighing arguments toward that value). Topics rotate bi-monthly, and competitive LD often involves pre-written cases and rapid delivery.
SuperDebate was created for those who love philosophical debate but want accessibility - no mandatory frameworks, no age restrictions, no months of case preparation.
The SuperDebate Format
Constructive
Build and present your original arguments. Make your case clearly and persuasively.
Cross-Examination
Question your opponent. Clarify positions and expose weaknesses in their arguments.
Rebuttal
Respond to your opponent's arguments and reinforce your own. Deliver your closing.
That's it. Three speech types, infinitely configurable. From 18-minute quick rounds to 60+ minute deep dives.
SuperDebate vs Lincoln-Douglas
| Feature | SuperDebate | Lincoln-Douglas (LD) |
|---|---|---|
| Participants | 1v1 to 5v5 (flexible) | 1v1 only (fixed) |
| Duration | 18-60+ min (4 presets) | ~45 min (fixed 32 min speaking + prep) |
| Preparation | Zero prep - topics at event | Extensive case writing required |
| Framework | No required framework | Value + Criterion structure mandatory |
| Topic Cycle | Fresh topics each event | Same topic for 2 months |
| Age/Status | Open to all ages | Primarily high school (NSDA) |
| Speaking Style | Natural, conversational | Often includes spreading at competitive levels |
| Learning Curve | Minimal - start immediately | Steep - months to master framework |
| Judging | Clear universal criteria | Varies by judge paradigm (traditional/progressive) |
| Cost | Free or minimal | Circuit fees, coaching, debate camps |
Why SuperDebate Works for Everyone
No Framework Required
Skip the value premise and criterion structure. Make arguments directly without mandatory philosophical scaffolding.
Flexible Team Sizes
Not locked into 1v1. Choose solo, 2v2, or team formats up to 5v5 based on your preference.
Zero Case Prep
No weeks of writing affirmative and negative cases. Topics assigned at the event - compete on quick thinking.
Open to Everyone
Not just high school students. Adults, professionals, and anyone can compete without age restrictions.
Natural Speaking
No spreading expected. Debate at conversational pace that audiences can follow and enjoy.
Philosophical Freedom
Engage with ethics and values on your terms. Philosophy is welcome but not structurally mandatory.
Common Questions
Other Format Comparisons
Ready to Try Accessible Debate?
No framework required. No case prep needed. Just show up and debate.